A warmly lit Brooklyn neighborhood restaurant with walnut tables, an olive banquette and a window overlooking brick buildings at blue hour.

Park Slope's Newest Fifth Avenue Restaurants Come From People Already on the Block

For about three years, the storefront at 147 Fifth Avenue was covered in "Coming Soon" wallpaper. A 2024 Google Street View image already shows it. In February, co-owner George Constantinou told WhatNow that the bank loan alone had taken 18 months, and that the restaurant was waiting on gas service before it could open in early March 2026.

Voodoo Queen finally opened on Tuesday, October 6. It serves gumbo, fried green tomatoes, shrimp and grits, smoked ribs and New Orleans-style cocktails between St. Johns Place and Lincoln Place.

The owners stuck with that storefront because they already had a stake on the avenue. Voodoo Queen is the fourth Fifth Avenue restaurant from Mil Gustos Hospitality. The group, run by Constantinou and Farid Ali, also owns Bogota Latin Bistro, Miti Miti and Medusa the Greek, all within a few blocks. The same is true of almost every restaurant that opened on Fifth Avenue between Prospect Place and Carroll Street since August: someone already connected to the block opened it.

A 122-year bakery family moved in next door to Miriam

Caputo Bagels opened on Monday, October 5, at 81 Fifth Avenue on the corner of Prospect Place. It took over the former Miriam Street Food space. James Caputo is the fifth-generation owner of Caputo Bake Shop, which closed in Carroll Gardens this past spring after 122 years. His partner is Rafi Hasid, chef and owner of Miriam, the Israeli restaurant right next door. Park Slope Pulse reported that the two have been friends for more than two decades, and that Caputo invested when Hasid expanded Miriam into Manhattan.

The bakery's history shows up on the menu. The $4 Lard Provolone Bagel works salami, lard and provolone into the dough, a bagel version of the lard bread Caputo Bake Shop was known for. The sourdough bagels are hand-rolled and take about two days to make, using a starter Caputo remembers his father using. That puts the starter at 45 years old or more. Eater NY noted open-face and breakfast sandwiches as well.

The details that matter on a weekday morning:

  • Seating: 25 seats, counter service, exposed brick, with a view into the baking kitchen
  • Hours: 7 a.m. to 3 p.m. Monday through Friday, 7 a.m. to 4 p.m. Saturday and Sunday
  • Next door: Miriam, Hasid's restaurant

Mil Gustos added a fourth restaurant to its own stretch. Caputo and Hasid did something close to that: one corner tenant passed the space to a partner instead of to a stranger.

Apapacho's owners started out a few blocks away

Apapacho opened at the beginning of August at 191 Fifth Avenue, between Berkeley Place and Union Street. Co-owner Jimmy Placido worked at Fonda in the South Slope and was on the team behind Alma Negra on Fourth Avenue. His partners are Acencion Mendez, also from Alma Negra, and his friend Jazmin Suarez. Placido told Park Slope Pulse that he got his start in restaurants in Park Slope 18 years ago and is now back as an owner.

The menu draws on the cooking of Mexico City, Oaxaca and Puebla. It includes Vieira Con Coco, which is pan-seared scallops with pasilla rice and coconut habanero salsa, and Enchiladas Norteñas, made with braised short ribs, queso fresco and mole rojo. The cocktail list focuses on tequila and mezcal. When Pulse asked the team for their favorite local spots, they named Fifth Avenue neighbors, including Miatzil, Blueprint, Black Oak and McMahon's Public House.

Mil Gustos expanded its own holdings, Caputo partnered with the restaurant next door, and Apapacho's owners spent years working nearby before opening their own place. All three paths start in the neighborhood.

One Georgian spot opened in July, and a second followed in October

The Georgian cluster grew differently. A first opening drew a second a few blocks away. Lileo, a Georgian coffee and wine bar, opened on July 2 at 86 Fifth Avenue, between Warren Street and St. Marks Place. On Thursday, October 22, Sesilya opened its bakery at 254 Fifth Avenue on the corner of Carroll Street, in the space Negril BK used to occupy. Its full-service restaurant is scheduled for later this year. Eater NY wrote that this part of Fifth Avenue is "quickly becoming a top destination" for Georgian food.

Co-owner David Kitiashvili moved to New York from Tbilisi more than twenty years ago. He opened Sesilya with childhood friends, and its dishes come from family recipes, including khachapuri. He told Park Slope Pulse why he picked this location:

"In our opinion, Park Slope is an exceptionally warm and welcoming neighborhood. It feels like everyone knows each other and is connected to what is happening around them."

The restaurant will also pour Georgian wines, and Kitiashvili plans to eventually offer private lessons on Georgian wine and its history.

Aokō Matcha is the one northern Fifth Avenue opening tied to a larger company. It soft-opened at 155 Fifth Avenue, between Lincoln and Berkeley Places, in the former TBaar space, and calls itself America's first matcha gelato cafe. The brand belongs to the same group as the Kyuramen ramen chain. On October 1, the group opened an Aokō Matcha counter alongside Kyuramen Express and Bao Dumpling at 40 Gold Street in the Financial District.

The national names opened on Seventh Avenue and in the South Slope

Seventh Avenue's openings over the same months came from chains, and they mostly took over spaces other chains had left:

  1. NAYA, the Lebanese fast-casual chain, opened on Wednesday, September 16, at 311 Seventh Avenue between Eighth and Ninth Streets. Dave's Hot Chicken used to occupy the space. It is the first NAYA in Brooklyn with a kids' menu.
  2. 16 Handles opened in late October at 148 Seventh Avenue. The chain's location page lists hours of 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. on Friday and Saturday.
  3. Taim, the Mediterranean chain, had closed its Seventh Avenue location by mid-August.

Fifth Avenue's southern end follows the same pattern. Park Slope Pulse's October 22 issue reported that Panda Express is taking 445 Fifth Avenue at Ninth Street, next to Chipotle. Both national names on Fifth Avenue sit at the South Slope end. From Prospect Place to Carroll Street, this season's openings came from people with roots on the block.

The difference shows up in the details. Caputo Bagels has a sourdough starter at least 45 years old. Apapacho's owners trained a few blocks away. Voodoo Queen's owners carried more than three years of delays on one storefront while running three restaurants nearby. Taking that kind of time and risk on one storefront is easier for an operator who already has customers on the street.

The next dates on the avenue

The Park Slope Fifth Avenue BID holds its 5th Avenue Tree Lighting for Small Business Saturday on Saturday, November 28, at 4:30 p.m. According to the BID's events calendar, a Menorah Lighting follows in December.

The BID's Park Slope Gift Card works like a Mastercard but only at participating local businesses on Fifth Avenue, Seventh Avenue and in Gowanus. It's a gift option for anyone on your list who lives near the avenue. Tree lighting night also lines up with the newest kitchens. Voodoo Queen is a few blocks north at 147 Fifth Avenue. Sesilya's bakery is at the Carroll Street corner, with the full restaurant due later this year. Caputo Bagels closes at 4 p.m. on Saturdays, so get there earlier in the day.

Knowing who runs which storefront on Fifth Avenue is the same street-level detail Maria Nica brings to advising clients in Park Slope. If you want a local read on the stretches of Fifth and Seventh Avenues closest to you, let's connect.

WORK WITH MARIA

Elevate your real estate journey with Maria Nica, where sophistication and seamless service converge. Maria's keen eye for detail and personalized approach ensures a tailored exploration of dream homes.

Follow Me on Instagram