Rain-softened limestone apartment entrance with a patinated bronze glass door and a tall curtained window beside it.

On St. Marks Place, Dessert Shops Replace Dessert Shops While Dinner Moves to First and Second Avenues

At 22 St. Marks Place, Bake Culture has closed. The Taiwan-based bakery chain opened there in May 2022, in a former pet-shop space that had been empty since the pandemic. It sold cakes, tarts and sweet and savory buns. Within two weeks, EV Grieve reported two new tenants for the same block between Second and Third avenues. Yo Dessert, a frozen yogurt, smoothie and gelato brand from Fort Lee, N.J., is coming to the lower level of 19-25 St. Marks Place, in the former T-swirl Crêpe space. Teazzi Tea Shop, a bubble and milk tea shop from Jersey City, is coming across the street.

The outlet's headline put it plainly: "(More) bubble tea and froyo for this block of St. Mark's Place." That sums up the fall in one line. The busiest block in the East Village is swapping one sweets counter for the next. Most of the season's restaurants with real tables, bars and dinner menus opened a few blocks north and east, on First Avenue, Second Avenue and East 10th Street.

The St. Marks block keeps refilling with the same kind of shop

This fall's turnover on and near St. Marks shows the pattern:

  • Reiwatakiya, a Japanese and Korean beauty and lifestyle shop at 37 St. Marks Place, closed on September 26. The brand still operates elsewhere.
  • Bake Culture at 22 St. Marks Place has closed. The chain still runs two other New York locations, including one at 48 Bowery.
  • Hokkaido Baked Cheese Tart, around the corner at 166 Second Avenue between East 10th and 11th streets, closed in October.
  • Yo Dessert and Teazzi Tea Shop are the incoming tenants named so far for the Second-to-Third block.

The names change and the menus stay much the same. An afternoon treat will always be easy to find on this block. A new place to sit down for dinner is rarer, and there's exactly one.

The one new dinner spot on St. Marks

Anderson Cafe & Restaurant opened at 41 St. Marks Place on Thursday, September 24, according to Eater NY's September openings roundup. Eater named Estela alum George Riddle as the head of the kitchen. Resy lists it as coming from the team behind Chez Ma Tante and Le Crocodile. The restaurant's own site lists evening hours only: Tuesday through Thursday 5 to 10 p.m., Friday and Saturday 5 to 11 p.m., and Sunday 5 to 10 p.m.

That makes Anderson the exception on St. Marks. Every other recent opening that runs on dinner reservations, late hours or a full bar is farther uptown or farther east.

Where the fall's restaurants actually opened

Starting from Second Avenue and East 10th Street and walking a few blocks in any direction, you pass most of the season's sit-down openings. Hours set them apart from a dessert counter, so here they are by when each one runs:

Place Address Opened Hours
Good Time Country Buffet 166 First Ave., between East 10th and 11th Sept. 12 Wed.–Sun., 5–10 p.m.; reservations and walk-ins
Anderson Cafe & Restaurant 41 St. Marks Pl. Sept. 24 Tue.–Sun. dinner, until 11 p.m. Fri.–Sat.
June Baby 197 Second Ave., between East 12th and 13th Oct. 28 Tue.–Sun., 4 p.m.–midnight; walk-ins only
FKA 221 Second Ave., between East 13th and 14th mid-September Daily, 4 p.m.–4 a.m.
Herbie's Burgers 109 First Ave., between East Sixth and Seventh September Daily, 11 a.m.–2 a.m.
Table Mercato 214 East 10th St., between First and Second Sept. 26 Opens 11 a.m., Tue.–Sun.

A few of these are worth more detail.

Resy's profile of Good Time Country Buffet names David JoonWoo Yun, Yong Min Kim and Steve JaeWoo Choi as owners. Eater NY's fall preview places it on First Avenue between East 10th and 11th streets, and that block is the hinge of the new cluster.

June Baby, a Filipino bar from co-owners Roxanne Diaz Bangalan, Darwin Pornel and Ben Rojo, opened on Wednesday, October 28, according to Eater NY. It takes no reservations.

Patch reports that FKA, short for Formerly Known As, comes from hospitality veterans Zak Snyder, Aram Sabet and Kyle O'Brien with entrepreneur Emerson Taymor. Eater describes it as a throwback cocktail bar with a raw bar and $1 East Coast oysters every day. It stays open until 4 a.m., the latest of anything on this list.

Table Mercato, from owner Jen Royle, is a counter-service spot with no seating, and its closing time varies by day, per EV Grieve.

Two more openings are off the table's grid but belong to the same shift.

Jam & Jaggery is a cocktail bar and restaurant from chef Aarthi Sampath, downstairs from her restaurant Drāvida at 211 First Avenue near East 13th Street. Eater dates its opening to Friday, September 18. Sampath told EV Grieve in late October that it had been open Fridays and Saturdays for several weeks.

Kotobuki, at 8 Stuyvesant Street at East Ninth Street, went back to full-service Japanese dining on Tuesday, September 29, according to Eater NY. EV Grieve reported that the move ended three years as a takeout-only restaurant and added a full bar, a first for this location. A takeout window turning back into a dining room is the clearest single example of the season's direction.

One new place on East 10th is a dessert cafe. Chong opened on Saturday, October 10, near Second Avenue. It serves Thai tea hot and iced, in flavors such as coconut, lime and lychee, plus thick toast topped with ice cream and Thai steamed bread with pandan or Thai-tea custard. Eater reports this on its October openings page and calls Chong part of a wave of tea-focused cafes across the city. Unlike the sweets counters on St. Marks, it's a sit-down cafe with a menu built around one specific style.

First Avenue lost two kitchens this fall, too

The northern blocks had departures of their own. Hunan Slurp Shop, at 112 First Avenue just south of East Seventh Street, closed on September 27. 345 Cantina, at 345 East Sixth Street just west of First Avenue, has also closed. The next opening farther down the avenue is again a restaurant. Matane, a Japanese restaurant planned for 59 First Avenue just south of East Fourth Street, is expected by the end of the year, according to EV Grieve.

Both corridors are turning over. On St. Marks, sweets counters replace sweets counters. On First and Second avenues, departing kitchens are being replaced by places that serve dinner.

Avenue B was rebuilt for the same evening crowd

The street itself changed this fall too, on the eastern edge of the cluster. The Department of Transportation announced on Tuesday, October 13, that it had finished redesigning Avenue B from Fourth Street to 14th Street, EV Grieve reported. The biggest changes are on the three blocks between Seventh and 10th streets beside Tompkins Square Park. Car traffic there is now one-way northbound, and cyclists can ride in both directions. Intersections have new curb extensions protected by planters, plus bike corrals and granite blocks. New loading zones at each end of every block are meant to cut down on truck traffic.

The Avenue B Open Street still runs 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. daily. Parks employees told EV Grieve that the planters along the park side would lose their flowers in the cold weather and get mini Christmas trees in their place.

Inside the park, a new mini forest has been planted along East Seventh Street between avenues A and B. EV Grieve reported the planting finished in early October.

What's next on the calendar

A few dated items for the coming weeks:

  1. Barnes & Noble at 181 Avenue A. The company's store page lists the store as "Opening November 2026." Management told EV Grieve it won't have a café.
  2. Drāvida's Thanksgiving feast. The restaurant's website is taking reservations for a South Asian and Indian Thanksgiving Feast on Thursday, November 26, upstairs from Jam & Jaggery.
  3. Matane at 59 First Avenue, expected by year's end.

If you're planning a weeknight dinner, start at East 10th and First or Second Avenue rather than St. Marks. Most of the new tables are within a few blocks of that corner, and Anderson is the one to book if you want to stay on St. Marks.

If you're thinking about living here and want to know how a specific building sits relative to the corners that fill up after dark, Maria Nica can walk those blocks with you at the hours that matter. Let's Connect.

WORK WITH MARIA

Elevate your real estate journey with Maria Nica, where sophistication and seamless service converge. Maria's keen eye for detail and personalized approach ensures a tailored exploration of dream homes.

Follow Me on Instagram