At 422 Forest Avenue, the storefront where Beans & Leaves poured coffee for years now sells warm cookies until 3 a.m. Thursday through Saturday. Crumbl is at 423, across the avenue. Shah's Halal Food is next door at 424. Beans & Leaves, open since 1997, moved down the block to 409 and still closes in the late afternoon.
The block shows the larger change on Forest Avenue. Over the past year, new openings have sorted themselves by time of day. The West Brighton stretch in the 300s and 400s has become a late-night strip. A mile or so up the avenue in Westerleigh, the most talked-about new restaurant takes the opposite approach: dinner only, made by one person, with no delivery.
The 400 block now stays open later than almost anywhere nearby
When Insomnia Cookies opened on July 3, SILive reported that it had been through a series of delays. Its hours were 11 a.m. to 1 a.m. Sunday through Wednesday and 11 a.m. to 3 a.m. Thursday through Saturday. It delivers to the College of Staten Island, West Brighton, Port Richmond, Castleton Corners, New Brighton and St. George. That range is why the shop keeps busy well after its neighbors close.
Its neighbors keep late hours too. Here is the strip from the 380s to the 470s, with hours as each business currently posts them:
| Address | Business | What it serves | Posted hours |
|---|---|---|---|
| 382 Forest Ave. | Randall Manor Tavern | Pub fare, pizza, house-made pasta | Noon to 2 a.m. |
| 409 Forest Ave. | Beans & Leaves | Coffee and café | 6:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. weekdays |
| 422 Forest Ave. | Insomnia Cookies | Cookies, ice cream, delivery | Until 1 a.m., 3 a.m. Thu–Sat |
| 423 Forest Ave. | Crumbl | Weekly rotating cookies | Until 10 p.m. Mon–Thu, midnight Fri–Sat |
| 424 Forest Ave. | Shah's Halal Food | Platters, gyros | Around 2 a.m. |
| 474 Forest Ave. | Saucy Wingz | Wings | 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. |
Most of these spots are recent. Randall Manor Tavern moved over from Castleton Avenue and reopened at 382 Forest on Nov. 4, 2025. Its kitchen is run by chef Steve Rowan, and John Venturella makes the pizzas, bread and pasta. Shah's opened at 424 in 2025, according to SILive's year-end roundup. Planet Wings at 474 closed in May 2026, and Saucy Wingz was in the space by June.
Crumbl is the steady presence on the block. SILive's Oct. 4 roundup of 2026 closings reported that the company shut its Charleston store at South Shore Commons, while the Forest Avenue shop kept drawing customers. SILive called the arrival of Insomnia across the avenue the start of "cookie wars."
Several closing times have shifted since opening. When Shah's opened, SILive reported it would serve until 3 a.m. Its ordering page now shows closing around 2 a.m. The same thing happened farther up the avenue, as the next section shows. Late hours on Forest Avenue are real, but they have come in one to two hours earlier than announced. Before a 2 a.m. food run, check the posted hours.
Up the avenue, the newest opening skips delivery
At 1210 Forest Avenue in Westerleigh, in the former Sofia's Guac Bar space, Favorite Son Pizza & Wine opened on Sept. 9. According to SILive's review, owner Danny Ippolito sells no slices, offers no delivery and takes no reservations. He works the galley kitchen alone, serves dinner from 5 to 10 p.m. six nights a week, and has had a line out the door at peak hours.
Ippolito has cooked at Carbone and Locanda Verde in Manhattan and previously owned Bin 5 on Staten Island. He told SILive he spent about six years working on the dough. The pizza is 100% sourdough made with organic flours from Italy and the West Coast, and he feeds the starter twice a day. His wife, Graceanne, works the counter with him.
"Many people don't realize sourdough is the original way bread was leavened, and it creates a depth of flavor that's difficult to achieve with commercial yeast," Ippolito told SILive.
The pizza comes on paper plates with a short wine list. There's a main dining room with a small bar and covered outdoor seating. It's the reverse of the 400 block. Insomnia's business depends on reaching people at home after midnight. Favorite Son only works if you show up by 10 p.m. and wait your turn.
The rest of upper Forest filled in around it
The other recent changes in Westerleigh do follow the late-night pattern, but fewer of them are open past 11.
- 1198B Forest Ave. Sumac, the Middle Eastern restaurant that served Westerleigh for 10 years, closed this summer. SILive reported that a halal grill called Tacojees was being built in the space. A restaurant directory now lists it as open since September, with Saturday hours of 11 a.m. to 11 p.m.
- 1267 Forest Ave. Tacobee's is a separate business despite the similar name. It opened as a halal Mexican spot after a January announcement promising tacos until 3 a.m. Its own location page now lists 11 a.m. to 1 a.m. daily.
- 814 Forest Ave. Garden Gourmet Café took over the old Sam Gregorio's Florist storefront, which held the florist from 2010 to 2023. It serves halal food, baked goods, salads, wraps, smoothies and coffee from 9 a.m. to 9 p.m.
- 1686 Forest Ave. Golden Creperie opened in August with breakfast, crepes, coffee and smoothies, posting hours of 7 a.m. to 10 p.m.
Tacobee's is the only one of these that stays open past midnight, and it now closes two hours earlier than first announced. Up here, the 1 a.m. closings are rare. The newer storefronts mostly serve daytime and early-evening customers, with Favorite Son's dinner service in the middle.
Storefronts still changing hands
A few spaces are still in transition, and they will help decide which way each stretch goes.
- 646 Forest Ave. Supreme Burger closed after about two years. SILive reported that Gyro City will take over the space.
- 1351 Forest Ave. The Popeyes has been closed since a health department closure in March 2026, and the same SILive roundup reports that Tex's Chicken & Burgers is planned for the space.
- 676 Forest Ave. Filoncino opened its bakery-café in the former Trattoria Vento space in June 2025. The company's locations page still lists the Forest Avenue shop, but its online ordering page currently says it is not taking orders.
Each of these could tip a stretch toward late-night takeout or daytime service. Gyro City and Tex's both fit the takeout formats already on the avenue.
Matching the stretch to the hour
The Forest Avenue BID covers the avenue from Broadway to Hart Boulevard and supports 149 ground-floor businesses. As of mid-October, its events page listed no upcoming events. Last year, its Trick or Treat for All was held Oct. 25, and the 20th Holiday Stroll was Dec. 4. Until the district posts this year's events, the restaurants' own hours are the best guide to the avenue:
- Morning coffee. Beans & Leaves at 409 opens at 6:30 a.m. on weekdays. Golden Creperie at 1686 opens at 7 a.m. every day.
- Sit-down dinner. Favorite Son at 1210 runs 5 to 10 p.m. and is closed Tuesdays. Arrive early, because there are no reservations. Randall Manor Tavern at 382 serves pizza and pasta later into the night.
- After 11 p.m. Head for the 400 block. Insomnia, Crumbl on Fridays and Saturdays, and Shah's are all within three doors of each other. Up the avenue, Tacobee's at 1267 is the late option.
- Delivery after midnight. Insomnia delivers from 422 to St. George, New Brighton, Port Richmond, Castleton Corners and CSI. Favorite Son does not deliver at all.
Maria Nica keeps track of which Forest Avenue storefronts change hands and how late they stay open, because that block-by-block detail comes up whenever clients compare the North Shore's neighborhoods. If you know a new Forest Avenue spot, or want to talk about how the North Shore's blocks compare, Let's Connect.